Stearns & Foster vs Beautyrest Mattresses

At Bedzzz Express, we know choosing between luxury brands like Stearns & Foster or Beautyrest can feel like deciding between a five-star steakhouse and an upscale sushi spot—both are amazing, but which one will satisfy your cravings?

If you're wondering whether Stearns & Foster or Beautyrest is the better fit for you, we’re here to break it down with the facts you need to know before making your decision.

 

 

Stearns & Foster vs. Beautyrest Comparison

Both brands have been around forever (or at least over 100 years), which means they’ve had plenty of time to perfect their craft. But they cater to different types of sleepers.

Now, let’s dive deeper into what makes each brand unique.

Why Choose Stearns & Foster?

Stearns & Foster is like the tailored suit of mattresses—high-end, thoughtfully crafted, and designed for people who want luxury sleep.

Pros:

✅ Premium materials like Indulge Memory Foam (developed by Tempur-Pedic) for exceptional pressure relief
✅ Tencel covers that wick away moisture, keeping you cool at night
✅ Hand-tufted craftsmanship for added durability and elegance
✅ Multiple firmness options, including ultra-plush and pillow-top designs

Cons:

❌ Higher price point
❌ Some models can feel too plush for those who prefer a firm, no-sink bed

Best Stearns & Foster Mattress for Side Sleepers:

Stearns & Foster Lux Estate Soft Euro Top Mattress (Model: 53008451) – Plush comfort with extra pressure relief for shoulders and hips.

Best Stearns & Foster Mattress for Back Sleepers:

Stearns & Foster Studio Tight Top Mattress (Model: 53001351) – Medium firmness for back support, along with innersprings that offer stability and reduced motion transfer.

Why Choose Beautyrest?

If Stearns & Foster is a tailored suit, Beautyrest is your favorite high-tech athletic gear—cooling, supportive, and built for performance.And if you’re after next-level comfort with advanced cooling and support, Beautyrest Black mattresses are worth the investment.

Pros:

✅ Great for hot sleepers—many models feature cool-to-the-touch fabric and RightTemp Memory Foam
✅ Pocketed coil technology minimizes motion transfer (great for couples)
✅ More budget-friendly than Stearns & Foster while still offering premium quality
✅ Available in different firmness levels, including extra-firm for back pain relief

Cons:

❌ Lacks some of the hand-crafted luxury details found in Stearns & Foster
❌ May not have the same plush, sinking-in feel that memory foam lovers crave

Best Beautyrest Mattress for Side Sleepers:

Beautyrest Black Series One Plush Mattress (Model: 7008121531050) – Plush support with contouring foam that keeps your spine aligned.

Best Beautyrest Mattress for Back Sleepers:

Beautyrest Black Hybrid KX-Class Firm Mattress (Model: 7008114961050) – Firm comfort with a lux layer of cashmere, alpaca and silk help keep you cool all night.

Which One Is Better for You?

Choosing between these two depends on how you sleep and what you value most in a mattress. Here’s a quick way to decide:

• Go with Stearns & Foster if: You love plush, cloud-like luxury with premium materials and don’t mind the higher price tag.

• Go with Beautyrest if: You want a cooler, supportive sleep at a slightly more affordable price, especially if you sleep hot or share your bed.

Either way, Bedzzz Express has you covered with a wide selection of both brands—so you can test them out in person and find your perfect fit.

Find Your Perfect Mattress at Bedzzz Express

At the end of the day, both Stearns & Foster and Beautyrest make high-quality mattresses, but the right one depends on your sleep style and comfort preferences.

Still unsure? Visit one of our mattress store locations  in Alabama, Georgia, contact us or shop online to find the best mattress for you. And remember, we offer a 3-year exchange policy, so you can sleep soundly knowing you’ve made the right choice. We also offer other top mattress brands, like Sealy, Serta, and Purple. 

👉 Browse mattresses at Bedzzz Express today!

Related readings from our blog:

• Tempur-Pedic Vs Purple

• Choosing Between Sealy & Serta Mattresses

• Top 5 Reasons To Buy A Luxury Mattress

FAQ: Stearns & Foster vs Simmons Beautyrest

1. Which is better, Stearns & Foster or Beautyrest?

It depends on your sleep preferences! Stearns & Foster offers luxury craftsmanship and plush comfort, while Beautyrest focuses on cooling technology and motion isolation—ideal for hot sleepers and couples.

2. Is Stearns & Foster a good mattress for seniors?

Yes! Many seniors love Stearns & Foster for its pressure relief and plush support, especially if they experience joint pain. The Estate Collection offers a great balance of softness and support.

3. Do Stearns & Foster mattresses need a box spring?

Not necessarily. While you can use a traditional box spring, Stearns & Foster mattresses work well with adjustable bases or solid foundations.

4. Is Beautyrest a good mattress?

Absolutely! Beautyrest is known for its cooling technology, pocketed coil support, and durability, making it a solid choice for most sleepers.

5. What’s the average lifespan of a Stearns & Foster mattress?

With proper care, a Stearns & Foster mattress can last 10–15 years—longer than many other brands due to its premium materials and construction.